Pam LogoPAM
  • Notetaker
    • Real EstateNew
    • For Managers
    • Blog
    • Changelog
    • Research
    • Open Source
  • Trust
Notetaker
Trust
Back to Blog
BUSINESS•November 19, 2026

How to Write Commercial Property Acquisition Criteria (Free Template)

Nick Shcherban
Nick Shcherban
Co-founder
10 min read
Share:

Ask three people on an acquisitions team what the firm buys and you'll often get three slightly different answers. The head of acquisitions says ground-floor retail, 70 to 120 m², near a supermarket. An analyst adds "unless the price per metre is silly". The newest hire describes whatever the last deal looked like.

They're all roughly right, because the criteria live in people's heads. That works until the market gets busy. Then every listing needs a conversation, two people assess the same property without knowing it, and a good unit sits in someone's inbox for a week because nobody is sure it fits.

This guide is about writing commercial property acquisition criteria down so that anyone on the team (or a piece of software) applies them the same way. There's a free template further down. It follows the structure we use when we set up PAM for a new client, minus the software.

What acquisition criteria are, and why teams rarely write them down

Acquisition criteria are the written rules your team uses to decide whether a commercial property is worth pursuing. Some firms call them investment criteria, and US investors usually call them a buy box. The rules do two jobs: they rule listings out quickly, and they rank the ones that are left.

Most teams I talk to have some version already. It sits in an investment memo, a slide from the last fundraising deck, or a pinned message in the team chat. What it usually lacks is detail. "Prime retail" means something different to everyone who reads it, and "good location" can't be checked by anyone who hasn't walked the street.

The usual objection is that a written list will box the team in, and that experienced people make better calls than a checklist. I have some sympathy for that. But the judgement is there either way. Writing it down makes it visible, lets new people use it, and gives you something to check later when a deal goes well or badly.

The six parts of an acquisition criteria sheet

A useful sheet has two kinds of rule. Dealbreakers are yes or no: if a listing fails one, it's out, whatever else it has going for it. Scoring criteria add points, and the total becomes the listing's priority score. Most of the six parts below contain a bit of each.

Asset type and size

Start with what you buy and what you don't. A retail buyer might take shops and restaurant units and exclude offices and warehouses. Then set the size band as a range in square metres, 70 to 120 m² for example, rather than "small units". Decide now what happens just outside the band. A 130 m² unit you could subdivide into two might be more interesting than a perfect 100 m² one, and if so the sheet should say so.

Location and catchment

List the cities, districts or streets you cover, and the ones you deliberately avoid. Then describe what makes a location work in terms someone can check from a map: walking distance to the nearest tram or metro stop, how many people live within ten minutes, whether the street is a through route. If you can only judge it on a visit, it isn't ready for the sheet yet.

Price and return targets

A price ceiling is the obvious one. A price per square metre band for each area you cover is more useful, because it lets you compare a 70 m² unit with a 120 m² one. If you buy let property, add your minimum yield. If you buy to add value, add the most you're prepared to spend on works. Price tends to rule out more listings than anything else, so get these numbers exact.

Footfall drivers and frontage

For retail, this is where most of the value is. Footfall drivers are the places that bring people past the door: supermarkets, pharmacies, post offices, schools, busy transport stops. Decide which ones count for you and how close they need to be. Pick a distance, say 300 metres, and stick to it.

Frontage matters nearly as much. Most tenants will pay more for a ground-floor unit with a wide window onto the street than for the same space round the corner or up a flight of stairs. You can judge a surprising amount of this from the listing photos: whether the unit is visible from the street, the state of the facade, who the neighbours are.

Tenant and lease

If you buy let property, write down what a good tenant looks like for you: the type of business, the remaining lease length, and the rent compared with the area. Some buyers want a tenant in place for income from day one. Others prefer vacant units they can re-let at a higher rent. Either is a sound strategy. The sheet just has to say which one is yours, because it flips how you score the same listing.

Dealbreakers

Last, the short list of things that end the conversation. Typical examples are a planning use you can't realistically change, a lease term below your minimum, structural problems visible in the photos, or an asking price so far above your ceiling that negotiation won't close the gap. Every dealbreaker will occasionally throw out a property you'd have liked, so only include the ones you'd defend in front of an investment committee.

Turning criteria into a priority score

Dealbreakers decide which listings stay. The priority score decides which of those you look at first.

The method I've seen work best is also the simplest. Give each scoring criterion a maximum of 1, 2 or 3 points, depending on how much it matters. A listing earns full points if it meets the criterion, partial points if it partly does, and nothing if it doesn't. The total is its priority score.

Six to ten scoring criteria are plenty. I'd also avoid scales of 1 to 10. Nobody can explain the difference between a 6 and a 7 in a meeting, whereas everyone can argue about whether something is worth 2 points or 3, and that argument is worth having.

This is a scoring set for a high-street retail buyer who prefers let property:

CriterionMax pointsHow to award them
Footfall drivers within 300 m31 point per driver (supermarket, pharmacy, post office, school, transport stop), up to 3
Footfall at peak hours33 if busy, 1 if moderate, 0 if quiet
Ground floor with street frontage22 if yes, 0 if not
Tenant in place22 if let at or near market rent, 1 if let below it, 0 if vacant
Price per m² against the area median22 if at or below the median, 1 if up to 10% above, 0 if more
Maximum12

A buyer who prefers vacant units would reverse the tenant row and probably add one for re-letting potential.

Worked example: scoring a ground-floor retail unit

Take the sample listing from PAM's product page: an 88 m² shop on the ground floor of a busy residential street, asking €980,000. It clears the dealbreakers, since it's retail, inside the 70 to 120 m² band, and at street level.

CriterionThe listingPoints
Footfall drivers within 300 mSupermarket, pharmacy and post office3 of 3
Footfall at peak hoursBusy3 of 3
Ground floor with street frontageYes, and visible from the street in the photos2 of 2
Tenant in placeLet at roughly market rent2 of 2
Price per m² against the area medianAbout €11,100 per m², above the median for the street0 of 2
Priority score10 of 12

A 10 out of 12 doesn't mean buy. It means this listing goes near the top of the pile and someone should call the agent today rather than next week. It also tells you, before that call, that price is the weak point, and that's a better place to start a negotiation than finding out halfway through.

Adapting the sheet for offices and industrial units

The same structure works for other property types, but the scoring rows change. An office buyer would swap footfall drivers for floor plate size, parking, distance to a main station and the energy rating. An industrial buyer would look at eaves height, yard depth, loading doors and drive time to the motorway.

Dealbreakers shift as well. For offices, an energy rating below the legal minimum for letting is a common one, unless upgrading the building is the whole point of the deal.

Checking your criteria against past decisions

Your first version will be wrong in places, and the quickest way to find out where is to score deals you've already decided on.

Pull 20 or 30 properties from the past year: ones you bought, ones you offered on and lost, and ones you passed on. Score each with the new sheet without looking at what happened. Then compare.

Two things tend to show up. Some properties you passed on will score well, which means there's a rule in someone's head that isn't on the sheet. And some you pursued will score badly, which means a weight is off or the team made an exception it never wrote down. Adjust, score them again, and repeat. Two or three rounds are usually enough to get the scores close to how the team would rank the same properties by hand.

After that, keep a light record. Whenever the team overrides a score, note the reason in a column next to it. A few months of those notes is the best input you'll have for the next version of the sheet.

How to use the template

The template is a spreadsheet with three tabs:

  1. A dealbreakers tab, with one rule per row and a yes or no answer for each listing.
  2. A scoring tab with the criteria from this article, their maximum points and a short rule for awarding them. Change the rows to match what you buy.
  3. A listing log. Paste in one listing per row, mark the dealbreakers, enter the points, and the sheet adds up the priority score so you can sort by it.

Fill in the first two tabs as a team, ideally in one meeting with whoever signs off deals. Expect some disagreement. If two people can't agree on a row, that's a criterion the team never actually settled, and it's much cheaper to find that out now than in the middle of a negotiation.

Download the acquisition criteria template (.xlsx)

From a spreadsheet to screening every listing

A spreadsheet works while volume is manageable. It gets harder when listings come in from several portals, agents and off-market contacts, when the same property appears three times at three prices, and when someone has to read every listing before it can be scored at all.

That was the position TKN Invest was in. TKN is a retail property company in a capital city in Eastern Europe, and its acquisitions team already had clear criteria. Finding, reading and assessing new listings still took about five days. TKN ran PAM alongside the team for two months. PAM collected listings from all of TKN's sources, merged the duplicates and scored every listing against TKN's own acquisition criteria.

Screening and first analysis now happen the same day, in three hours on average, and one person screens the market that seven used to split between them. TKN's criteria stayed much the same. The difference is that every listing has a score before anyone opens it, so the team spends its time on the ones near the top.

Same day

Screening and first analysis

Down from about 5 days

3 hours

On average

To find, read and assess new listings

7×

Screening capacity

One person screens what seven used to split

If you want to see that with your own criteria, here is how PAM screens every listing against your acquisition criteria.

See your criteria applied to every listing

PAM tracks listings across your sources and scores each one against your acquisition criteria. Bring your criteria sheet to the call and we'll show you how it works on your market.

Useful AI. Real value.

Get updates from Pam on practical AI use cases, product news, and what actually delivers. Enter your business email to receive updates from Pam. See our privacy policy for details. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Ask AI for a summary about Pam

resources

Blog

Newsletter

solutions

Real Estate

For Managers

company

Research

Trust Center

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service